Keep Pueblo and Pueblo West separate when choosing pickup. South Prairie Avenue is in Pueblo; the North McCulloch branch below is in Pueblo West. They have different phone numbers and ordering pages.
City reference photograph, not a restaurant image. Myotus; original photo; CC0. Resized for display.
Local branches and menu links
Pueblo: South Prairie Avenue
1175 S Prairie Avenue, Pueblo, CO 81005
Restaurant phone: 719-564-9611
View this branch on Little Caesars
Pueblo West: North McCulloch
74 N McCulloch, #110, Pueblo West, CO 81007
Restaurant phone: 719-547-8828
View this branch on Little Caesars
What to compare on the Pueblo menu
Before comparing a lunch portion with a large pizza, check the included food and drink. A lunch combo, a whole deep-dish pizza and a Slices-N-Stix product are different quantities even when their pictures look similar.
Lunch combo guide · Deep-dish menu guide
How much does a pizza cost in Pueblo?
No local checkout price has been independently confirmed for this guide. Choose the branch, pickup or delivery, the exact crust and toppings, then review tax and applicable fees before payment. Our main menu guide contains separately dated examples; they are not prices verified for Pueblo.
Hours and pickup availability
Open the branch listing for today’s hours and available order times. There is no single citywide closing time. Call the restaurant before a visit near closing, a holiday order or a large pickup. An online order window can differ from posted store hours.
Is Pueblo West the same pickup location as South Prairie Avenue?
No. Check the community, street and ZIP code on your order confirmation. Do not assume an order placed for North McCulloch can be collected at the Pueblo branch.
Before placing your order
Check the address on the confirmation screen, item quantity and selected pickup time. For ready-to-go availability, see how HOT-N-READY works. For app collection instructions, see the Pizza Portal pickup guide.
Sources and scope
Location references reviewed October 19, 2026: Pueblo: South Prairie Avenue · Pueblo West: North McCulloch. Listings can change; hours, stock, delivery coverage and prices should be checked with the selected restaurant. This is an independent guide, not a restaurant website or a complete city directory.
See the editorial policy for source handling and reference pictures. For ingredients and dietary questions, consult the official US nutrition guide and your selected restaurant.